Encountering another’s suffering can elicit both empathic distress and empathic care—the warm desire to affiliate. It remains unclear whether these two feelings can be accurately and differentially predicted from neural activity and to what extent their neural substrates can be distinguished. Ashar et al. developed fMRI markers predicting the intensity of two different empathic emotions in response to naturalistic, dynamic stimuli. The markers predicted charitable donations, were supported by distinct large-scale brain systems, and were differentially related to eight other feelings.